Best Amazon Echo speaker: the lineup's Dots, Spots, Shows and Pluses compared

What started as a lineup of just one speaker, the original Amazon Echo, has recently expanded to include almost a half-dozen different devices. 

Now as well as a newly revamped standard Amazon Echo you've got a beefier Amazon Echo Plus, and a budget Amazon Echo Dot.

But that's not all. Amazon has also been hard at work introducing screens into the Amazon Echo ecosystem via the Amazon Echo Show and smaller Amazon Echo Spot.  

Confused? We don't blame you. 

Here’s our ranking of the Amazon Echo lineup as it currently stands, including all the devices that have been announced and are yet to be released. We’ve divided the list into two sections depending on whether they have a screen or not, and we've omitted the left-field Amazon Echo Look because it's just so different from the rest of the lineup. 

The screen-less Echos

Amazon Echo (2nd gen)

The new version of the Amazon Echo made a number of changes compared to its predecessor. It switch to using a pair of buttons to control volume, it replaced its matt plastic in favor of fabric, wood and metallic finishes, and it added a 3.5mm jack to allow it to be hardwired into an external speaker. 

It's also the perfect entrypoint into the Amazon Echo ecosystem. It might lack the bigger sound and smart home hub of the larger Plus, but we wouldn't say the price difference is quite worth the improvement. 

Read our full review: Amazon Echo

The Amazon Echo Dot is a much smaller version of the Amazon Echo, and is around the size of a hockey puck. There have actually been two generations of the Echo Dot released, with the second ditching the volume dial in favor of two dedicated volume buttons. 

The Dot’s size meant that some compromises on sound quality had to be made, resulting in a sound level that’s fairly weak and tinny and unsuitable for playing music. However, an included 3.5mm jack means that it’s perfectly possible to connect the speaker to an external sound system if you want to get your tunes playing. 

We wouldn't advise you to buy this speaker if you want to do a lot of music listening, but if you want to try out Alexa on the cheap or you're buying it for non-music queries, then the Dot is a fantastic budget buy. 

Read the full review: Amazon Echo Dot

The Amazon Echo Plus is a speaker that’s much more similar in appearance to the original 1st generation Amazon Echo. 

Under the hood, however, there have been a number of improvements made. The most significant of these is the addition of a ZigBee-compatible hub. 

Zigbee is the connection protocol used by a number of different smart home devices, which usually come with a hub that must be plugged into your router in order to allow them to function. 

Having a hub inside the Echo itself means that you no longer need this additional hub plugged into your router. In theory, so long as your Echo is connected to your home network then your smart home devices will function. 

But in practice, smart home functionality is limited when using the built-in hub, and so you'll probably want to keep using an external one to get the most out of your devices. 

Combined with the price premium, the Amazon Echo Plus offers probably the weakest value proposition of the three speakers. 

Read our full review: Amazon Echo Plus

The screen-equipped Echos

The first Echo device to be equipped with a screen, the Amazon Echo Show is able to show you a wealth of information that would be impossible on a regular Amazon Echo. 

A picture is worth a thousand words after all. 

As well as displaying visual information, the Show is also capable of playing video content from a variety of sources including, of course, Amazon Prime Video. 

The screen can also be used for video calls or to stream a video feed from compatible smart cameras. 

We're not convinced Amazon has built enough screen-enabled functionality to make its screen a must-have inclusion, but what it can do it does competently. 

Read our full review: Amazon Echo Show

The Amazon Echo Spot is a miniature version of the Show. It turns the 7-inch rectangular screen of the show into a 2.5-inch circular screen. 

This smaller screen means the device is less useful as a video-watching device. Although this is still supported, the round screen doesn't lend itself that well to long-form video viewing. Instead, you’re more likely to use the small screen to read messages, show virtual clock-faces, or conduct video calls. 

Its small size also means that the built-in speaker isn’t as good as the larger Show’s. But, in our brief tests with the device, it is better than its small form actor would have you believe.

Amazon is positioning this as a compact device that you might want to have on a bedside table as opposed to the Show’s countertop-sized form-factor. Its size also makes it a great kitchen or desk gadget. And, whisper it, it's the best-looking Echo device around at the moment

Read our initial impressions of the speaker here: Amazon Echo Spot

• Read about Amazon's closest competitor, the Google Home smart speaker

posted by Campus94